The Next Evolution of TV Advertising: Why Data Isn’t Enough

The promise of hyper-targeted efficiency has come at the cost of mass cultural relevance, with ads that optimize for clicks instead of emotional connection.

By Jack Myers

For the past decade, the advertising industry has worshiped at the altar of data. Every campaign, every media buy, every creative decision is justified through an avalanche of metrics—CPMs, GRPs, ROAS, impressions, attribution models, and programmatic efficiencies. Data has become the currency of decision-making, a security blanket for executives who want every move to be quantifiable.

Yet, despite the billions spent on audience targeting, analytics, and automated media buying, something is missing. Advertising effectiveness is in decline, audiences are tuning out, and brands are struggling to create meaningful connections. The problem isn’t that data is useless — it’s that data alone is not enough.

The Limits of Data-Driven Thinking

The industry’s over-reliance on data has led to a paradox: the more precise our targeting becomes, the less impact advertising seems to have. Personalization, once seen as the holy grail, often feels intrusive and uninspired. The promise of hyper-targeted efficiency has come at the cost of mass cultural relevance, with ads that optimize for clicks instead of emotional connection.

Consider the golden era of television advertising. Brands like Coca-Cola, Nike, and Apple didn’t win hearts and minds by optimizing for a 0.02% increase in engagement. They won by creating narratives that resonated across generations. Their ads were not just seen but remembered, talked about, and woven into culture.

Today, TV advertising is drowning in data but starving for creativity. The industry is obsessed with optimizing media delivery, yet it has lost sight of what truly makes advertising work: emotion, storytelling, and cultural insight.

Creativity Is the Real Competitive Advantage

The irony is that in an age of overwhelming media fragmentation, creativity matters more than ever. When consumers are bombarded with content across streaming platforms, social media, and digital experiences, only the most culturally relevant, emotionally compelling, and surprising advertising will break through.

The best-performing TV ads don’t succeed because they are perfectly targeted; they succeed because they are impossible to ignore. Look at the resurgence of long-form brand storytelling in Super Bowl ads, where companies invest millions not just in ad space, but in ideas that demand attention. These campaigns are driven by human insight, not just machine learning.

Even in the world of AI and programmatic buying, creativity remains the greatest force multiplier. The brands that thrive in the next era of TV advertising will be those that use data not as a crutch, but as a tool to amplify big, bold creative ideas. Order Jack Myers new book The Tao of Leadership: Harmonizing Technological Innovation with HUMAN Creativity in the AI Era: $0.99 Kindle version at Amazon.

Rebalancing the Equation: Data + Human Ingenuity

To restore the effectiveness of TV advertising, we must shift from a data-first mindset to a creativity-first strategy. This doesn’t mean abandoning data—it means using it in service of better storytelling.

Here’s four recommendations for subscribers of what the future demands plus TV advertising’s next chapter.